Which one of the following is true for the phenomenon of Liquidity Trap ?
Economics · Unit 2
Macro Economics
Revision notes (27 min read), then 48 real questions from UGC NET papers.
Official syllabus · Unit 2
- National income: concepts and measurement
- Determination of output and employment: classical and Keynesian approach
- Consumption function
- Investment function
- Multiplier and accelerator
- Demand for money
- Supply of money
- IS–LM model approach
- Inflation and Phillips curve analysis
- Business cycles
- Monetary and fiscal policy
- Rational expectations hypothesis and its critique
Verbatim from the UGC NET Bureau syllabus.
How often it is asked
| Paper | Questions |
|---|---|
| December 20257 Jan 2026 | 11 / 100 |
| June 202529 Jun 2025 | 13 / 100 |
| June 2024 (re-exam)28 Aug 2024 | 10 / 100 |
| December 202312 Dec 2023 | 14 / 100 |
Average 12.0 questions (24 marks) per paper. Unit tagging is ours.
Scope: national accounts; classical vs Keynesian output determination; consumption, investment, multiplier–accelerator; money demand and supply; IS–LM; inflation and the Phillips curve; business cycles; stabilisation policy; rational expectations and the critique. Notation: Y = output, C = consumption, I = investment, G = government spending, T = taxes, i or r = interest rate, b or c = MPC.
1. National Income: Concepts and Measurement
Identities
GDP(MP) = C + I + G + (X − M).GNP = GDP + NFIA, where NFIA = net factor income from abroad.NDP = GDP − depreciation(consumption of fixed capital).GDP at factor cost = GDP at MP − (indirect taxes − subsidies).- National income = NNP at factor cost.
- Personal income = NI − undistributed profits − corporate tax − social security contributions + transfer payments.
- Disposable income = personal income − personal direct taxes.
Three methods, which are equal in principle:
- Product / value-added: gross value of output − intermediate consumption. Avoids double counting.
- Income: compensation of employees + operating surplus (rent, interest, profit) + mixed income.
- Expenditure: final expenditure.
What is excluded and included
- Excluded: transfer payments, second-hand sales (only the brokerage counts), purely financial transactions, intermediate goods, and illegal and household (non-market) services.
- Included: imputed rent of owner-occupied housing, own-account production of goods, and the change in inventories.
Nominal, real and price indices
- Real GDP = nominal GDP / deflator.
- The GDP deflator is a Paasche-type, current-weighted index. The CPI is a Laspeyres-type, base-weighted index.
- The CPI overstates inflation because of substitution bias (Boskin Commission 1996, US).
Pioneers and frameworks
- Petty and Gregory King (17th century).
- Simon Kuznets: US national income estimates; Nobel 1971.
- Richard Stone: SNA framework; Nobel 1984.
- The UN System of National Accounts (SNA) has editions in 1953, 1968, 1993, 2008 and 2025. The 2025 edition was adopted by the UN Statistical Commission in March 2025; that date is from my own knowledge and was not verified for these notes.
India (historical)
- Dadabhai Naoroji made the first estimate (for 1867–68), in Poverty and Un-British Rule in India (1901).
- V.K.R.V. Rao gave the first scientific estimates (1931–32).
- National Income Committee 1949, chaired by P.C. Mahalanobis.
- CSO, now NSO under MoSPI. Since the 2015 revision (base 2011-12), sectoral output is measured as GVA at basic prices:
GVA at basic prices = GVA at factor cost + production taxes − production subsidies. - As of Nov 2026, check MoSPI for any newer base-year series; this was not verified for these notes.
Other measures
- Green GDP / SEEA: environmentally adjusted accounting.
- Measure of Economic Welfare: Nordhaus–Tobin 1972.
- HDI: UNDP 1990, Mahbub ul Haq and Amartya Sen.
Commonly tested
- NI = NNP at FC. GDP at MP − net indirect taxes = GDP at FC. GNP − GDP = NFIA.
- Kuznets ↔ national income accounting. Stone ↔ SNA. Naoroji ↔ first Indian estimate. Mahalanobis ↔ 1949 National Income Committee.
- Transfer payments are excluded; imputed rent is included. The deflator is Paasche; the CPI is Laspeyres.
2. Determination of Output and Employment: Classical & Keynesian Approach
Classical model (Smith, Ricardo, J.S. Mill, Say, Pigou)
- Say's law (J.-B. Say, Traité, 1803): supply creates its own demand. General overproduction is impossible.
- Labour market: wages and prices are flexible.
W/P = MPLfrom labour demand; labour supply depends on the real wage. The result is full employment, and any unemployment is only voluntary or frictional. - Output is fixed by the production function at full employment, so aggregate supply (AS) is vertical.
- Saving–investment equality comes through the interest rate (loanable-funds market).
- Money is neutral, via the quantity theory
MV = PY: there is a dichotomy between the real and monetary sectors. - Pigou (The Theory of Unemployment, 1933): wage cuts cure unemployment.
Keynes, The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money (1936)
- Effective demand is set by the point where aggregate demand equals aggregate supply. Equilibrium can occur at less than full employment.
- Money wages are rigid downward, and workers resist money-wage cuts (money illusion).
- Saving and investment are equalised by changes in income, not the interest rate.
- The interest rate is a monetary phenomenon set by liquidity preference.
- A wage cut may not raise employment because it lowers aggregate demand (AD).
- Paradox of thrift (Mandeville's Fable of the Bees; Keynes): a rise in desired saving can leave total saving unchanged or lower.
- Keynesian cross:
Y = C + I + G, withC = a + bY, gives equilibriumY* = (a + I + G)/(1 − b).
Responses and synthesis
- Pigou effect (Pigou 1943, EJ): falling prices raise real wealth (M/P), which raises consumption. This escapes the liquidity trap, so unemployment equilibrium needs rigidity.
- Real balance effect: Patinkin, Money, Interest and Prices (1956). Integrated monetary and value theory; criticised the classical dichotomy.
- Keynes effect: a falling price level raises real money balances (M/P), which lowers r and raises I. It fails in a liquidity trap or when investment is interest-inelastic.
- Neoclassical synthesis: Hicks, Hansen, Modigliani (1944), Samuelson. The economy is Keynesian in the short run and classical in the long run.
| Classical | Keynesian | |
|---|---|---|
| Labour market | clears, flexible W | rigid money wage |
| AS | vertical | horizontal/upward-sloping (short run) |
| S = I via | interest rate | income |
| Money | neutral (QTM) | affects r, Y (liquidity preference) |
| Unemployment | voluntary/frictional | involuntary possible |
| Policy | laissez-faire | active fiscal policy |
Commonly tested
- Say 1803 ↔ "supply creates its own demand". Keynes 1936 ↔ effective demand / involuntary unemployment. Pigou 1943 ↔ real wealth effect. Patinkin 1956 ↔ real balance effect, integration of value and monetary theory.
- Modigliani 1944 ↔ "Liquidity Preference and the Theory of Interest and Money", which shows rigid wages drive the Keynesian result.
3. Consumption Function
Absolute income hypothesis (Keynes 1936)
C = a + bY, with 0 < MPC < 1.- APC > MPC, and APC falls as income rises.
- Keynes's "fundamental psychological law": consumption rises with income, but by less.
Kuznets puzzle (Kuznets 1946)
- US long-run data for 1869–1938 show a roughly constant APC, about 0.86–0.88.
- Cross-section and short-run data show APC falling with income.
- The theories below try to reconcile the two findings.
Relative income hypothesis, Duesenberry, Income, Saving and the Theory of Consumer Behavior (1949)
- Demonstration effect: consumption depends on one's income relative to others.
- Ratchet effect: consumption depends on the previous peak income.
C/Y = a − b(Y/Y0), where Y0 is the past peak. - Consumption is irreversible downward.
- Brady & Friedman (1947) made a related relative-income argument.
Permanent income hypothesis, M. Friedman, A Theory of the Consumption Function (1957)
Y = Yp + YtandC = Cp + Ct, withCp = k(i, w, u)·Yp.- Transitory income is uncorrelated with permanent income and with transitory consumption, so the MPC out of transitory income is about 0.
- Permanent income is estimated by adaptive expectations: a weighted average of past incomes.
Life-cycle hypothesis (Modigliani & Brumberg 1954; Ando & Modigliani 1963, AER)
- People smooth consumption over the lifetime: hump-shaped saving, with dissaving in retirement.
C = αW + βYL, where W is wealth and YL is labour income.- APC = α(W/Y) + β, which is constant in the long run if W/Y is stable.
- National saving depends on growth and demographics.
- Modigliani won the Nobel in 1985.
Other contributions
- Fisher, The Theory of Interest (1930): two-period intertemporal choice; the basis of the PIH and LCH.
- Hall (1978, JPE): under rational expectations with the PIH, consumption follows a random walk, so only surprises change C.
- Excess sensitivity: Flavin 1981.
- Excess smoothness: Deaton.
- Rule-of-thumb consumers: Campbell–Mankiw 1989.
- Buffer-stock saving: Carroll.
- Hyperbolic discounting: Laibson 1997.
- Ricardian equivalence: see Section 11.
Commonly tested
- Keynes ↔ absolute income. Duesenberry 1949 ↔ relative income / demonstration and ratchet effects. Friedman 1957 ↔ PIH. Modigliani–Brumberg 1954 / Ando–Modigliani 1963 ↔ LCH.
- Kuznets ↔ constant long-run APC. Hall 1978 ↔ random walk of consumption. Fisher 1930 ↔ intertemporal choice.
4. Investment Function
Keynes (1936): marginal efficiency of capital (MEC)
- The MEC is the discount rate r that makes the present value of expected returns equal to the supply price of the asset:
C = Σ Rt/(1+r)^t. - Invest while MEC > i.
- Fisher's (1930) "rate of return over cost" is the precursor.
- Investment depends on animal spirits, i.e. expectations. Autonomous vs induced investment.
Marginal efficiency of investment (MEI)
- Lerner (The Economics of Control, 1944): allows for the rising supply price of capital goods.
- The MEI is the investment demand curve, I(i). It is less elastic than the MEC.
Accelerator — Aftalion (1909/1913), J.M. Clark (1917, JPE, "Business Acceleration and the Law of Demand")
K = vY, soIn = v(Yt − Yt−1), where v is the capital–output ratio (accelerator).- Assumptions: no excess capacity, fixed v, symmetric operation. Weaknesses: it ignores excess capacity and expectations, and does not work in reverse.
Flexible accelerator / capital stock adjustment (Goodwin 1948; Chenery 1952; Koyck 1954)
It = λ(K* − Kt−1)with 0 < λ < 1.
Neoclassical theory of investment (Jorgenson 1963, AER)
- Desired capital:
K* = αPY/c, with user cost of capitalc = PK(r + δ − expected capital gain), adjusted for taxes.
Tobin's q (Tobin 1969, JMCB; Brainard & Tobin 1968)
q = market value of firm / replacement cost of capital.- Invest if q > 1.
- Marginal q equals average q under linear homogeneity (Hayashi 1982).
Other theories
- Profits / internal funds: Meyer & Kuh 1957; Kalecki.
- Financing hierarchy: Modigliani–Miller 1958 irrelevance; pecking order (Myers & Majluf 1984).
- Irreversibility and the option value of waiting: Dixit & Pindyck 1994.
Commonly tested
- Keynes ↔ MEC. Lerner ↔ MEI. Clark 1917 / Aftalion ↔ accelerator. Goodwin / Chenery / Koyck ↔ flexible accelerator.
- Jorgenson 1963 ↔ user cost. Tobin 1969 ↔ q. Modigliani–Miller 1958 ↔ capital structure irrelevance.
5. Multiplier and Accelerator
Investment multiplier
- R.F. Kahn (1931, EJ, "The Relation of Home Investment to Unemployment") introduced the employment multiplier. Keynes (1936) developed the investment multiplier.
k = ΔY/ΔI = 1/(1 − MPC) = 1/MPS.- The size of the multiplier depends on leakages: saving, taxes, imports, debt repayment and idle balances.
- The multiplier works in reverse, and in real terms only when there is spare capacity.
Variants
- Lump-sum tax: G multiplier =
1/(1−b); tax multiplier =−b/(1−b); transfer multiplier =b/(1−b). - Balanced-budget multiplier = 1 (Haavelmo 1945, Econometrica; also Gelting, Wallich).
- Proportional tax t:
1/[1 − b(1−t)]. - Open economy:
1/(s + m)or1/[1 − b(1−t) + m], where m is the marginal propensity to import (MPM). The foreign trade multiplier is linked to Harrod. - Static (logical) vs dynamic (period) multiplier. The dynamic version is a geometric series
ΔI(1 + b + b² + …). - Super-multiplier (Hicks 1950): combines the multiplier with induced investment.
Interaction of multiplier and accelerator (Samuelson 1939, REStat, crediting Hansen)
- Model:
Yt = Ct + It + G,Ct = bYt−1,It = v(Ct − Ct−1). - This gives
Yt = b(1+v)Yt−1 − bvYt−2 + G. - Characteristic roots are real if
b(1+v)² ≥ 4v. The path is stable ifbv < 1. - Possible outcomes:
- real roots, bv < 1: monotonic convergence;
- complex roots, bv < 1: damped oscillation;
- bv = 1: constant-amplitude cycles;
- complex roots, bv > 1: explosive oscillation;
- real roots, bv > 1: explosive monotonic growth.
Hicks's trade cycle (A Contribution to the Theory of the Trade Cycle, 1950)
- With the accelerator large enough to make the cycle explosive, a full-employment ceiling and a floor set by autonomous investment and the inoperative downward accelerator turn it into bounded cycles around a rising trend.
Commonly tested
- Kahn 1931 ↔ employment multiplier. Keynes ↔ investment multiplier. Haavelmo 1945 ↔ balanced-budget multiplier = 1.
- Clark ↔ accelerator. Samuelson 1939 ↔ multiplier–accelerator interaction. Hicks 1950 ↔ ceiling/floor and super-multiplier.
- Worked example: MPC = 0.8 gives k = 5; with t = 0.25, k = 1/(1 − 0.6) = 2.5.
6. Demand for Money
Quantity theories
- Fisher (The Purchasing Power of Money, 1911): transactions version
MV + M'V' = PT. Velocity is institutionally fixed, so P ∝ M. - Cambridge cash-balance version (Marshall; Pigou 1917, QJE; Robertson; Keynes's Tract 1923):
M = kPY, with k = 1/V. It emphasises money as a store of value, and k is behavioural.
Keynes (1936): liquidity preference
- Three motives:
- Transactions and precautionary demand:
L1(Y). - Speculative demand:
L2(r), inversely related to r. It rests on the expected bond price and the "normal" interest rate, with each individual holding all-money or all-bonds.
- Transactions and precautionary demand:
Md/P = L1(Y) + L2(r).- Liquidity trap: at a very low r, everyone expects r to rise (bond prices to fall), so speculative demand is perfectly elastic. Monetary policy is then ineffective. Keynes called it a possibility; it was formalised by Hicks/Robertson.
Baumol–Tobin inventory model (Baumol 1952, QJE; Tobin 1956, REStat)
- Brokerage cost b per withdrawal, income Y, interest i, n withdrawals.
- Total cost
= nb + iY/(2n). - Optimal withdrawals
n* = √(iY/2b). Average money holdingM* = √(bY/2i). This is the square-root rule. - Income elasticity is ½ (economies of scale in cash holding); interest elasticity is −½.
- Transactions demand is therefore interest-sensitive, unlike in Keynes.
- Extensions: Miller–Orr (1966) stochastic firm cash; Whalen (1966) precautionary demand.
Portfolio and asset approaches
- Tobin (1958, RES, "Liquidity Preference as Behavior Towards Risk"): risk-averse individuals hold diversified portfolios of money and bonds. This explains the downward-sloping L2 at the individual level, with substitution and income effects of interest.
- Friedman (1956, "The Quantity Theory of Money: A Restatement"): money is an asset.
Md/P = f(Yp, rb, re, πe, w, u).- Money demand is stable and depends on permanent income.
- It is interest-inelastic in practice.
- The theory is one of the demand for money, not of prices.
Commonly tested
- Fisher 1911 ↔ MV = PT. Marshall/Pigou ↔ M = kPY. Keynes ↔ three motives + liquidity trap. Baumol 1952 / Tobin 1956 ↔ square-root rule.
- Tobin 1958 ↔ portfolio choice under risk. Friedman 1956 ↔ restatement / stable money demand. Miller–Orr ↔ stochastic cash management.
7. Supply of Money
- High-powered money / monetary base:
H = C + R(currency + reserves). In India, RBI's reserve money M0 = currency in circulation + bankers' deposits with RBI + other deposits with RBI. - Money multiplier:
M = mHwithm = (1 + c)/(c + r).- c = currency–deposit ratio; r = reserve–deposit ratio (with excess reserves e:
(1+c)/(c + r + e)). - m falls when c or r rises.
- Simple deposit multiplier = 1/r.
- c = currency–deposit ratio; r = reserve–deposit ratio (with excess reserves e:
- Determinants (Friedman–Schwartz; Cagan): H is set by the central bank, r by banks and the central bank, and c by the public.
- Exogenous vs endogenous money:
- Monetarist view: the central bank controls the money supply; vertical Ms.
- Post-Keynesian view: Kaldor (The Scourge of Monetarism, 1982); Moore (Horizontalists and Verticalists, 1988). Money is endogenous: loans create deposits, and the central bank sets the interest rate (horizontal Ms).
- Liquidity approach: Radcliffe Committee (UK 1959) on the "whole liquidity" of the economy. Gurley & Shaw (1960) on non-bank financial intermediaries.
- Instruments that change the supply: open market operations (OMO), the bank rate / policy repo rate, reserve requirements (CRR, SLR), and qualitative/selective credit controls.
- India: RBI aggregates per the Second Working Group, 1977. These definitions are long-standing; the RBI Handbook / WSS was not checked for these notes, so verify the current set.
M1 = currency with public + demand deposits with banks + other deposits with RBIM2 = M1 + savings deposits with post office savings banksM3 (broad money) = M1 + time deposits with banksM4 = M3 + total post office deposits- The Reddy Working Group (1998) added NM1–NM3 and liquidity aggregates L1–L3.
Commonly tested
- m = (1+c)/(c+r). Friedman & Schwartz 1963 ↔ A Monetary History of the United States. Radcliffe 1959 ↔ overall liquidity. Gurley–Shaw 1960 ↔ financial intermediaries.
- Kaldor/Moore ↔ endogenous money. M3 ↔ broad money (India).
8. IS–LM Model Approach
- Origin: Hicks (1937, Econometrica, "Mr. Keynes and the 'Classics': A Suggested Interpretation"), originally the "IS–LL" diagram. Hansen (Monetary Theory and Fiscal Policy 1949; A Guide to Keynes 1953) popularised it, hence "Hicks–Hansen". Meade and Harrod (both 1937) produced similar systems.
- IS curve (goods market,
Y = C(Y−T) + I(r) + G). It slopes downward and is flatter the larger the multiplier and the more interest-elastic investment is. - LM curve (money market,
M/P = kY − hr). It slopes upward and is flatter the higher h is (horizontal in the liquidity trap) and the lower k is. - Equilibrium (Dornbusch–Fischer–Startz notation):
Y = γĀ + γ(b/h)(M/P), withγ = αG/(1 + kbαG/h)andαG = 1/[1 − c(1−t)].- Fiscal multiplier = γ, which is smaller than αG because of crowding out.
- Monetary multiplier = γb/h.
| Case | Fiscal policy | Monetary policy |
|---|---|---|
| Liquidity trap (LM horizontal, h → ∞) | fully effective (no crowding out) | ineffective |
| Classical case (LM vertical, h = 0) | ineffective (100% crowding out) | fully effective |
| Investment inelastic (IS vertical, b = 0) | fully effective | ineffective |
| IS flat (b large) | weak | strong |
- AD curve: derived from IS–LM by varying P (via M/P). It slopes downward because of the Keynes effect (plus the Pigou effect).
- Open economy: Mundell–Fleming (Fleming 1962; Mundell 1963). With perfect capital mobility:
- Flexible exchange rate: monetary policy is effective, fiscal policy is not.
- Fixed exchange rate: fiscal policy is effective, monetary policy is not.
- The impossible trinity (trilemma) follows.
- Critiques: a static model, with no expectations, a fixed P, and stock–flow problems. Hicks later (1980) called it a "classroom gadget".
Commonly tested
- Hicks 1937 ↔ IS–LM. Hansen ↔ popularisation. Vertical LM ↔ classical / monetarist. Horizontal LM ↔ Keynesian liquidity trap.
- Mundell–Fleming ↔ open-economy IS–LM–BP. Crowding out is greater when LM is steeper or IS is flatter.
9. Inflation and Phillips Curve Analysis
Types of inflation
- Demand-pull: excess demand. Keynes's inflationary gap (How to Pay for the War, 1940).
- Cost-push: wage-push, profit-push, supply shocks.
- Structural: Latin American structuralists (Sunkel, Prebisch, Seers), driven by bottlenecks in agriculture and the external sector.
- Mixed / sectoral: Schultze 1959.
- Monetarist view: Friedman, "inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon" (1963; repeated 1970).
- Hyperinflation: Cagan (1956) defined it as > 50% per month.
- Stagflation: inflation together with unemployment (1970s).
- Costs of inflation: shoe-leather and menu costs; arbitrary redistribution (from creditors to debtors and from fixed-income earners); seigniorage and the inflation tax.
- Fisher equation:
i = r + πe(Fisher 1896/1930). Fisher effect: a one-for-one rise in i when πe rises. The Mundell–Tobin effect says r falls somewhat when π rises.
Phillips curve and its evolution
- A.W. Phillips (1958, Economica): an inverse, non-linear relation between money-wage growth and unemployment in the UK, 1861–1957.
- Lipsey (1960): theoretical underpinning (excess demand for labour).
- Samuelson & Solow (1960, AER): restated it in terms of price inflation (US), offering a "menu" of choices between inflation and unemployment.
- Friedman (1968, AEA presidential address "The Role of Monetary Policy", AER) and Phelps (1967, Economica; 1968, JPE): the expectations-augmented Phillips curve.
π = πe − β(u − un).- Under adaptive expectations (Cagan 1956), the Phillips curve is vertical at the natural rate in the long run.
- Accelerationist hypothesis: keeping u < un requires ever-accelerating inflation.
- NAIRU: introduced by Modigliani & Papademos (1975) as "NIRU". It is close to, though not definitionally identical with, Friedman's natural rate.
- Rational expectations (Lucas, Sargent–Wallace): the Phillips curve is vertical even in the short run for anticipated policy.
- Hysteresis: Blanchard & Summers (1986). The natural rate depends on the history of actual unemployment.
- Sacrifice ratio: % of output lost per 1-point cut in inflation.
- New Keynesian Phillips curve:
πt = βEtπt+1 + κxt, with Calvo (1983) pricing and Taylor (1980) staggered contracts. - Okun's law (Okun 1962):
- Original estimate: each 1 percentage point of unemployment above 4% ↔ roughly 3% output gap.
- Modern estimates are around 2. For example, Mankiw's version:
Δu ≈ −½(g − 3%)for the US.
- Misery index (Okun): inflation + unemployment.
Commonly tested
- Phillips 1958 ↔ wage inflation vs unemployment (UK). Samuelson–Solow 1960 ↔ price Phillips curve. Lipsey 1960 ↔ rationalisation.
- Friedman 1968 / Phelps 1967 ↔ natural rate, expectations-augmented Phillips curve. Modigliani–Papademos 1975 ↔ NAIRU. Blanchard–Summers 1986 ↔ hysteresis.
- Okun 1962 ↔ output gap–unemployment. Cagan 1956 ↔ hyperinflation / adaptive expectations. Keynes 1940 ↔ inflationary gap.
10. Business Cycles
Phases: expansion (recovery, boom), peak, contraction (recession, depression), trough.
Cycle lengths
| Cycle | Length | Associated cause |
|---|---|---|
| Kitchin (1923) | inventories | |
| Juglar (1862) | ~7–11 years | fixed investment |
| Kuznets (1930) | ~15–25 years | building / demographic |
| Kondratieff (1925–26) | ~45–60 years | long waves; Schumpeter linked them to innovation clusters |
Theories
- Sunspot / agricultural: Jevons (1875–78).
- Purely monetary: Hawtrey (Good and Bad Trade, 1913). Bank credit expansion and contraction drive the cycle; the trade cycle is "a purely monetary phenomenon".
- Monetary over-investment (Austrian): Hayek (Prices and Production, 1931), building on Wicksell's natural vs market rate. Credit makes the market rate fall below the natural rate, leading to excessive roundabout production and then collapse. Mises also contributed.
- Innovation: Schumpeter (Business Cycles, 1939); "creative destruction" (Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy, 1942).
- Psychological: Pigou (Industrial Fluctuations, 1927); Keynes's "animal spirits".
- Keynesian: fluctuations in the MEC.
- Multiplier–accelerator: Samuelson 1939; Hicks 1950 (ceiling and floor).
- Non-linear models: Kaldor (1940, EJ) with S-shaped I and S functions; Goodwin (1951) non-linear accelerator; Goodwin (1967) growth cycle (Lotka–Volterra class struggle).
- Political business cycle: Kalecki (1943, Political Quarterly); Nordhaus (1975, RES), electoral cycles.
- Equilibrium monetary misperception: Lucas (1972 JET; 1975 JPE), the "islands" model. Agents confuse aggregate with relative price changes, so unanticipated money causes cycles.
- Real business cycles (RBC): Kydland & Prescott (1982, Econometrica, "Time to Build and Aggregate Fluctuations"); Long & Plosser (1983, JPE).
- Cycles are efficient responses to real (technology) shocks, i.e. Solow residuals, with intertemporal labour substitution.
- Money is neutral, and there is no role for stabilisation policy.
- Kydland and Prescott won the Nobel in 2004.
- New Keynesian: menu costs (Mankiw 1985, QJE); near-rationality (Akerlof & Yellen 1985); coordination failures; efficiency wages.
- Debt-deflation: Fisher (1933); Minsky's financial instability hypothesis.
Commonly tested
- Hawtrey ↔ purely monetary cycle. Hayek ↔ over-investment. Schumpeter ↔ innovations. Kaldor 1940 ↔ non-linear cycle. Hicks 1950 ↔ ceiling and floor.
- Nordhaus 1975 / Kalecki 1943 ↔ political business cycle. Kydland–Prescott 1982 ↔ RBC. Lucas ↔ islands / monetary misperception. Kitchin ↔ inventory cycle, Kondratieff ↔ long waves.
11. Monetary and Fiscal Policy
Goals and frameworks
- Goals: price stability, full employment, growth, external balance.
- Tinbergen rule (On the Theory of Economic Policy, 1952): number of instruments ≥ number of targets.
- Mundell's assignment rule (1962, IMF Staff Papers): principle of effective market classification. Assign monetary policy to external balance and fiscal policy to internal balance (under fixed exchange rates).
- Swan diagram (1955): internal and external balance.
Monetary policy
- Instruments:
- quantitative: OMO, bank rate / policy rate (repo), reserve ratios (CRR, SLR);
- qualitative: margin requirements, credit rationing, moral suasion, direct action.
- Transmission channels: interest rate; credit (bank lending and balance sheet, Bernanke–Gertler 1995); exchange rate; asset prices (Tobin's q, wealth); expectations.
- Lags: inside lags (recognition, decision) and outside lags (Friedman's "long and variable" lags).
- Rules vs discretion:
- Friedman's k-percent rule (constant money growth).
- Taylor rule (Taylor 1993):
i = r* + π + 0.5(π − π*) + 0.5(y − y*). Taylor used r* = 2% and π* = 2%. The Taylor principle: the nominal rate should move more than one-for-one with inflation. - Time inconsistency: Kydland & Prescott (1977, JPE, "Rules Rather than Discretion"). Discretion gives an inflation bias.
- Credibility and reputation: Barro & Gordon (1983).
- Conservative central banker: Rogoff (1985, QJE).
- Inflation targeting: New Zealand first, 1990.
- India: flexible inflation targeting under the amended RBI Act 1934 (Finance Act 2016) with a six-member MPC. Target CPI 4% ± 2% was notified for Aug 2016–Mar 2021 and retained for Apr 2021–Mar 2026. Source: RBI / Government of India notification (March 2021). The arrangement after March 2026 was not verified for these notes.
- Liquidity trap / zero lower bound: unconventional tools include quantitative easing and forward guidance.
Fiscal policy
- Functional finance: Lerner (1943, Social Research). Judge the budget by its effects, not its balance.
- Compensatory fiscal policy: Hansen.
- Automatic (built-in) stabilisers: progressive taxes and unemployment benefits. Their drawback is fiscal drag. Contrast with discretionary policy.
- Crowding out: via the interest rate (IS–LM). Complete crowding out occurs with a vertical LM.
- Ricardian equivalence: Barro (1974, JPE, "Are Government Bonds Net Wealth?"); Buchanan (1976) named it after Ricardo, who himself doubted it in practice.
- Debt-financed tax cuts do not change consumption, because people save to pay future taxes.
- It needs infinite horizons (bequests), perfect capital markets and lump-sum taxes.
- Laffer curve: tax revenue vs tax rate (Laffer, 1970s).
- Fiscal dominance: Sargent & Wallace (1981), "Some Unpleasant Monetarist Arithmetic". Persistent deficits can force future money creation.
- Policy mix: Keynesians favour fiscal policy; monetarists favour rules and money.
- India: FRBM Act 2003.
Commonly tested
- Tinbergen 1952 ↔ targets = instruments. Mundell 1962 ↔ assignment problem. Taylor 1993 ↔ policy rule. Friedman ↔ k% rule, long and variable lags.
- Kydland–Prescott 1977 ↔ time inconsistency. Barro–Gordon 1983 ↔ credibility. Rogoff 1985 ↔ conservative central banker.
- Barro 1974 ↔ Ricardian equivalence. Lerner 1943 ↔ functional finance. Sargent–Wallace 1981 ↔ unpleasant monetarist arithmetic.
12. Rational Expectation Hypothesis and its Critique
Expectation schemes compared
- Static:
Pe_t = Pt−1. - Adaptive (Cagan 1956; Nerlove 1958):
Pe_t − Pe_t−1 = λ(Pt−1 − Pe_t−1). Backward-looking, with systematic errors. - Rational (J.F. Muth 1961, Econometrica, "Rational Expectations and the Theory of Price Movements"):
- Subjective expectations equal the mathematical expectation conditional on all available information, including the correct model:
Pe_t = E[Pt | It−1]. - Forecast errors are random with mean zero, so there are no systematic errors.
- Muth applied it to microeconomic (cobweb) markets.
- Subjective expectations equal the mathematical expectation conditional on all available information, including the correct model:
New Classical Macroeconomics
- Lucas (1972, JET, "Expectations and the Neutrality of Money"; 1973 AER). Lucas supply function:
y = y* + β(P − Pe). Only unanticipated money affects output. - Policy ineffectiveness proposition (PIP): Sargent & Wallace (1975, JPE; 1976, JME). With RE plus continuous market clearing, systematic (anticipated) monetary policy cannot affect real output or unemployment; only surprises can.
- Barro (1977, AER): empirical tests of unanticipated money growth.
- Lucas critique (Lucas 1976, "Econometric Policy Evaluation: A Critique", Carnegie-Rochester Conference Series on Public Policy, vol. 1):
- Parameters of reduced-form econometric models are not policy-invariant, because agents' decision rules change when policy changes.
- Hence models need "deep" (structural) parameters such as tastes and technology. This spurred microfounded, DSGE models.
- Credibility: the time-inconsistency literature (Kydland–Prescott 1977) and disinflation without cost if credible ("Ends of Four Big Inflations", Sargent 1982).
- Nobels: Lucas 1995; Sargent (with Sims) 2011; Kydland–Prescott 2004.
Critiques
- Sticky wages and prices: Fischer (1977, JPE) and Phelps & Taylor (1977) used overlapping or staggered contracts; Taylor (1980). Even with RE, systematic monetary policy affects output, which restores a role for policy (New Keynesian).
- Markets do not clear continuously: coordination failures, menu costs, efficiency wages.
- Information and learning costs: bounded rationality (Simon); learning models (Sargent 1993; Evans & Honkapohja 2001). Grossman–Stiglitz (1980) paradox: informationally efficient markets are impossible if information is costly.
- Empirical evidence: Mishkin (1982, JPE) found anticipated money also affects output. Large disinflation costs (Volcker 1979–82) went against the costless-credibility prediction. Shiller (1981) found excess volatility of stock prices.
- Unrealistic informational demands: agents must know the true model. Behavioural evidence (Kahneman, Thaler) shows systematic biases.
- Observational equivalence (Sargent 1976): natural-rate/RE models and Keynesian models can fit the same data.
- RE does not by itself imply PIP. PIP needs RE plus flexible prices.
| School | Expectations | Phillips curve | Policy |
|---|---|---|---|
| Keynesian (1960s) | static/none | stable trade-off | fine-tuning |
| Monetarist (Friedman) | adaptive | short-run trade-off, vertical in the long run | k% rule |
| New Classical (Lucas, Sargent–Wallace) | rational | vertical even in the short run (anticipated) | ineffective if systematic |
| New Keynesian (Fischer, Taylor, Mankiw) | rational + rigidities | short-run trade-off | effective |
| RBC (Kydland–Prescott) | rational | irrelevant (real shocks) | none needed |
Commonly tested
- Muth 1961 ↔ RE. Lucas 1972 ↔ neutrality of money. Lucas 1976 ↔ critique. Sargent–Wallace 1975/76 ↔ PIP. Barro 1977 ↔ unanticipated money.
- Fischer 1977 / Taylor 1980 ↔ sticky-contract critique. Kydland–Prescott 1977 ↔ rules vs discretion. Kydland–Prescott 1982 ↔ RBC.
Last-minute 20 facts
- NI = NNP at factor cost. GDP(MP) − net indirect taxes = GDP(FC).
- Say 1803: supply creates its own demand. Keynes 1936: effective demand, involuntary unemployment.
- Kahn 1931: employment multiplier. k = 1/MPS. Balanced-budget multiplier = 1 (Haavelmo 1945).
- Clark 1917 (and Aftalion): accelerator, In = vΔY. Samuelson 1939: interaction model, stable if bv < 1.
- Duesenberry 1949: relative income (demonstration and ratchet effects).
- Friedman 1957: PIH; MPC out of transitory income ≈ 0.
- Modigliani–Brumberg 1954 / Ando–Modigliani 1963: LCH, C = αW + βYL.
- Hall 1978: consumption is a random walk.
- Keynes: MEC. Lerner 1944: MEI. Jorgenson 1963: user cost. Tobin 1969: q > 1 ⇒ invest.
- Baumol 1952 / Tobin 1956: M* = √(bY/2i); income elasticity ½, interest elasticity −½.
- Liquidity trap: horizontal LM; monetary policy ineffective, fiscal fully effective.
- Money multiplier = (1+c)/(c+r).
- Hicks 1937: IS–LM ("Mr. Keynes and the Classics"); Hansen popularised it.
- Phillips 1958 (UK, 1861–1957); Samuelson–Solow 1960 (price version).
- Friedman 1968 / Phelps 1967: natural rate; LRPC vertical. Modigliani–Papademos 1975: NAIRU.
- Okun 1962: originally ~3% output per 1 point of unemployment; modern ~2.
- Taylor 1993: i = r* + π + 0.5(π − π*) + 0.5·output gap, with r* = π* = 2.
- Muth 1961: RE. Lucas 1976: critique. Sargent–Wallace 1975/76: PIP.
- Kydland–Prescott: 1977 time inconsistency; 1982 RBC (Nobel 2004).
- Barro 1974: Ricardian equivalence. Fischer 1977 / Taylor 1980: sticky contracts restore policy effectiveness.
Sources
- Dornbusch, Fischer & Startz, Macroeconomics (IS–LM multipliers γ, money multiplier, Baumol–Tobin, Phillips curve).
- Mankiw, Macroeconomics (Okun's law version, consumption theories, Taylor rule, Ricardian equivalence).
- Blanchard, Macroeconomics. Romer, Advanced Macroeconomics (Lucas model, RE, RBC, New Keynesian Phillips curve, Fischer contracts). Froyen, Macroeconomics: Theories and Policies (classical vs Keynesian, schools comparison).
- Samuelson (1939) multiplier–accelerator conditions, cross-checked: https://python.quantecon.org/samuelson.html ; Tramontana & Gardini (2021), https://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s40008-021-00239-3
- Original papers as cited inline (Hicks 1937 Econometrica; Phillips 1958 Economica; Friedman 1968 AER; Muth 1961 Econometrica; Lucas 1976 Carnegie-Rochester; Sargent & Wallace 1975 JPE; Kydland & Prescott 1977 JPE, 1982 Econometrica; Taylor 1993 Carnegie-Rochester).
- RBI (inflation-target notification, March 2021; monetary aggregates definitions): https://www.rbi.org.in
Practice: 48 real questions
Newest papers first. Pick an option to check yourself; your progress is saved on this device.
Recently, Inflation rates have trended downward and approaching steadily Central Bank target levels.
In this context, which of the following are correct ?
A. Supply chains are adopting the economic uncertainties
B. Easing monetary policy
C. Tighter monetary policy
D. Increase in AD is more than increase in AS
Choose the correct answer from the options given below :
A. Innovation Theory of Business cycle was given by Jorgenson
B. Pure Monetary Theory of Business cycle was given by Hawtrey
C. Monetary-over-investment Theory of Business cycle was given by Clark
D. Multiplier-Acceleration Interaction Theory of Business cycle was given by Samuelson
Choose the correct answer from the options given below :
Match List - I with List - II.
| List - I | List - II |
|---|---|
| A. Debt-deflation theory | I. Falling price levels raises the income levels |
| B. Pigou effect | II. A policy of announcing future monetary action |
| C. Forward guidance | III. The effects of unexpected fall in price level could depress income |
| D. Okun's law | IV. An inverse relationship between unemployment and real GDP |
Choose the correct answer from the options given below :
Which one of the following is NOT true about rational expectation ?
For the given information regarding an economy, the value of equilibrium level of income is :
C = 100 + 0.75Yd; G = 40; I = 60; t = 0.2
Here, C = consumption, Yd = disposable income, G = Govt. expenditure, I = Investment, t = tax rate
Choose the correct statements :
A. The 'q' theory emphasises that the investment increases when assets are valuable relative to their reproduction cost.
B. With a fixed exchange rate fiscal expansion under free capital mobility is completely ineffective in raising output.
C. Under Investment tax credit, government pays part of the cost of investment.
D. Under fixed exchange rate and perfect capital mobility a country cannot pursue an independent monetary policy.
Choose the correct answer from the options given below :
Given GNP at market price Rs. 14400 crores, consumption Rs. 12000 crores, government purchases Rs. 1200 crores, exports Rs. 1000 crores and imports Rs. 1500 crores, the value of investment will be :
In case of balanced budget multiplier :
A. Output increases less than the increase in government spending.
B. Output increases more than the increase in government spending.
C. Government spending and taxes are raised in equal amounts.
D. The value of multiplier is equal to 1.
Choose the correct answer from the options given below :
Given below are two statements : one is labelled as Assertion (A) and the other is labelled as Reason (R).
Assertion (A) : Deficit spending by the government leads to crowding out effect on private investment.
Reason (R) : When the government finances its deficit by borrowing from the market, the bond prices go up and the rate of interest falls.
In the light of the above statements, choose the most appropriate answer from the options given below :
Match List - I with List - II.
| List - I | List - II |
|---|---|
| A. Q theory | I. Unemployment and inflation |
| B. Phillips curve | II. Unemployment and output |
| C. Okun's Law | III. Investment |
| D. Liquidity trap | IV. Demand for money and interest rate |
Choose the correct answer from the options given below :
In the context of classical economics, an increase in money supply causes.
If the value of Keynesian investment multiplier is 4, which one of the following will be the corresponding saving function?
Which of the following causes a positive output gap, where, output gap=Actual output – Potential output ?
In the context of IS-LM model, a higher marginal propensity to spend results in :
If the marginal propensity to consume is 0.8 and initial increase in tax revenues by the government is Rs. 100, then the impact on national income would be:
Which of the following is likely to lead to a rise in the output cost of disinflation?
According to Lucas Critique.
Arrange the following works of J. M. Keynes in chronological order (Starting from the oldest to latest).
A. A Treatise on Money
B. General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money
C. Indian Currency and Finance
D. A Monetary Theory of Production
E. A Tract on Monetary Reform
Choose the correct answer from the options given below :
According to classical economics, an increase in government deficit spending leads to.
A. a shift in the demand for loanable fund to the right
B. decline in interest rate
C. increase in investment
D. increase in saving equal to decline in consumption
E. decrease in investment and consumption that balances the increase in government spending.
Choose the correct answer from the options given below :
Which of the followings are the effects of increase in government spending in IS-LM framework in a closed economy?
A. Increase in income by multiplier times government expenditure.
B. Shift in IS curve to the right leading to disequilibrium in money market at given level of interest rate.
C. Quantity of money demand will be higher.
D. Interest rate will decrease.
E. Private investment will increase leading to increase in aggregate demand.
Choose the correct answer from the options given below :
Which of the followings are true about New Classical approach.
A. The main protagonist was R.E. Lucas Jr.
B. It is based on adaptive expectation.
C. It was developed during 1950s.
D. Complete wage and price flexibility.
E. Difference between actual and expected price is a random error.
Choose the most appropriate answer from the options given below :
Which of following are not an assumptions of policy ineffectiveness propositions?
A. Rational expectation
B. Policy changes are not anticipated
C. Economic agents have full information
D. Nominal variables influence economic decision
E. Output and employment are at their natural level
Choose the most appropriate answer from the options given below :
Match List-I with List-II :
| List-I (Concepts) | List-II (Given by) |
|---|---|
| A. Paradox of thrift | I. K. Boulding |
| B. Water-Diamond paradox | II. A.C. Pigou |
| C. Wage employment paradox | III. J.M. Keynes |
| D. Macroeconomic paradox | IV. Adam Smith |
Choose the correct answer from the options given below :
The rise in the nominal stock of money causes :
Suppose savings function is S = −5 + 0.3q, then find the correct answer from below :
In the leakage-injection approach to income determination, an increase in lump-sum tax ceteris paribus shifts :
As per Walras' law the sum of excess demand for money, bonds and current output must be equal to ________.
The phrase 'demonstration effect' was coined by :
Gross domestic Product or GDP is defined as :
The concept of efficiency wage theory was developed by :
Arrange the following in chronological order starting from earliest to latest :
(A) A.W. Phillips : The Phillips Curve
(B) J.M. Keynes : General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money
(C) Adam Smith : Theory of Growth
(D) John F. Muth : Rational Expectations Approach
(E) Robert M. Solow : Growth Model
Choose the correct answer from the options given below :
Inflation confers no benefits on society, but it imposes several real costs. What among the following are costs of inflation ?
(A) Shoeleather costs associated with reduced money holdings
(B) Menu cost associated with more frequent adjustmental prices
(C) Increased variability of relative prices
(D) Unintended changes in tax liabilities due to nonindexations of the tax code
(E) Arbitrary redistribution of wealth associated with debts
Choose the correct answer from the options given below :
Consider the following statements and identify the correct ones ?
(A) According to the accelerator models, investment demand is proportional to the change in GNP.
(B) The real rate is the nominal rate of interest plus the inflation.
(C) The higher the real interest rate, the higher is the rental cost of capital.
(D) Investment is a stock concept
(E) Rate of interest is a flow concept
Choose the correct answer from the options given below :
In March, 2023 the consumer price index (CPI) of a country with a 1982 base index of 100, was 234.7. This means the cost of purchasing the market basket of goods and services :
If the interest rate is exogenously determined by the Central Bank of some country and the money supply is endogenously determined, the slope of the LM-curve in the interest rate-income plane would be :
Higher fiscal deficit to GDP ratio would necessarily cause inflation if the economy is under :
An economy characterised by huge involuntary unemployment would have an aggregate labour supply curve in a real wage-labour supply plane that would be :
Suppose an economy is in medium-run equilibrium. Now the government enacts a law, making entry of new firms difficult, which increases the monopoly power of the existing firms. Which of the following statements are true about this change ?
(A) Output level will be lower in medium-run
(B) Output level will be lower in short-run
(C) Price level will be higher in medium-run
(D) Price level will be higher in short-run
Choose the correct answer from the options given below :
Consider the following statements about the Aggregate Demand (AD) relation under price flexibility and say which ones are correct ?
(A) The AD curve will shift to the right if autonomous investment rises.
(B) The AD curve will shift to the right if net exports rise in an open economy.
(C) The AD curve will shift to the left if money supply contracts.
(D) As price rises, shifting the LM curve, the AD curve shifts to the left
Choose the correct answer from the options given below :
Given the following statements about major schools of thought in macroeconomics, state which ones are correct ?
(A) The Keynesians believed in wage and price flexibility and highlighted the role of aggregate supply.
(B) The monetarists highlighted the importance of money in the economic system and that of expectations in the analysis of inflation.
(C) The classical school believed in the invisible hand and the efficiency of the market mechanism
(D) The new Keynesians make use of the assumption of imperfect markets in their frameworks.
Choose the correct answer from the options given below :
Match the following :
| List - I (Theory) | List - II (Economist(s) who gave it) |
|---|---|
| (A) Permanent Income Hypothesis of Consumption | (I) T. Sargent and N. Wallace |
| (B) Life-cycle Hypothesis of Consumption | (II) Milton Friedman |
| (C) Real Business Cycle Theory | (III) Franco Modigliani |
| (D) Policy Ineffectiveness Proposition | (IV) F. Kydland and E. Prescott |
Choose the correct answer from the options given below :
Match List - I with List - II.
| List - I (Property) | List - II (Type of Curve) |
|---|---|
| (A) Investment is unresponsive to interest rates | (I) Relatively flat IS curve |
| (B) Money demand is perfectly elastic w.r.t. interest rates | (II) Vertical LM curve |
| (C) Money demand is completely inelastic w.r.t. interest rates | (III) Horizontal LM curve |
| (D) Investment is highly responsive to interest rates | (IV) Vertical IS curve |
Choose the correct answer from the options given below :
Match List - I with List - II.
| List - I | List - II |
|---|---|
| (A) Quantity theory of money | (I) Milton Friedman |
| (B) Involuntary unemployment | (II) John Maynard Keynes |
| (C) Randomised trial | (III) Abhijit V. Banerjee |
| (D) Relative poverty | (IV) Amartya K. Sen |
Choose the correct answer from the options given below :
Arrange the given schools of thought in macroeconomics in chronological order, from the oldest to most recent one.
(A) The Keynesian school
(B) The new classical school
(C) The classical school
(D) The new Keynesian school
(E) The monetarists
Choose the correct answer from the options given below :
Passage / data
According to the NSO, MOSPI press release dated 31st May 2023, the revised estimate of GDP at the current price for the year 2021-22 was Rs. 2,34,71,012 crores and that for 2020-21 was Rs. 1,98,29,927 crores. The GDP at 2011-12 constant prices for the year 2020-21 and 2021-22 were Rs. 1,36,87,118 crores and Rs. 1,49,25,840 crores respectively. At the current prices, the net taxes on products was Rs. 20,32,128 crores in 2021-22(RE). The PFCE, GFCE, GFCF in 2021-22 were Rs. 1,43,44,336 crores, Rs. 26,25,361 crores and Rs. 67,86,391 crores respectively. Change in stocks(CIS), valuables and discrepancies in 2021-22 were Rs. 1,63,438 crores, Rs. 3,79,112 crores and Rs. (−) 208,247 crores (negative) respectively in current prices.
What was the inflation rate in India based on the GDP deflators ?
Same passage / data as the previous question
According to the NSO, MOSPI press release dated 31st May 2023, the revised estimate of GDP at the current price for the year 2021-22 was Rs. 2,34,71,012 crores and that for 2020-21 was Rs. 1,98,29,927 crores. The GDP at 2011-12 constant prices for the year 2020-21 and 2021-22 were Rs. 1,36,87,118 crores and Rs. 1,49,25,840 crores respectively. At the current prices, the net taxes on products was Rs. 20,32,128 crores in 2021-22(RE). The PFCE, GFCE, GFCF in 2021-22 were Rs. 1,43,44,336 crores, Rs. 26,25,361 crores and Rs. 67,86,391 crores respectively. Change in stocks(CIS), valuables and discrepancies in 2021-22 were Rs. 1,63,438 crores, Rs. 3,79,112 crores and Rs. (−) 208,247 crores (negative) respectively in current prices.
The Gross Value Added (GVA) at basic prices in 2021-22 was :
Same passage / data as the previous question
According to the NSO, MOSPI press release dated 31st May 2023, the revised estimate of GDP at the current price for the year 2021-22 was Rs. 2,34,71,012 crores and that for 2020-21 was Rs. 1,98,29,927 crores. The GDP at 2011-12 constant prices for the year 2020-21 and 2021-22 were Rs. 1,36,87,118 crores and Rs. 1,49,25,840 crores respectively. At the current prices, the net taxes on products was Rs. 20,32,128 crores in 2021-22(RE). The PFCE, GFCE, GFCF in 2021-22 were Rs. 1,43,44,336 crores, Rs. 26,25,361 crores and Rs. 67,86,391 crores respectively. Change in stocks(CIS), valuables and discrepancies in 2021-22 were Rs. 1,63,438 crores, Rs. 3,79,112 crores and Rs. (−) 208,247 crores (negative) respectively in current prices.
In 2021-22, the investment GDP ratio in India was :